Pages

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Death thou shalt die

In Measure for Measure the whole plot centers around death.  Death as penance for something that is wrong, death as feared, death as accepted . . . etc.  Everything being said really made me think.

As Isabella states, "The sense of death is most in apprehension, and the poor beetle that we tread upon in corporal sufferance finds a pang as great as when a giant dies."  In a kind of gross, but very dramatic way Isabella is talking about how precious life is.  The focus is on sin and punishment, the action and then the consequence.  However, instead of constructing the play around justice and mercy, Shakespeare explores the idea of true verses false.



The executioner of justice himself becomes polluted by the sin he is trying to get rid of.  How does this change the story?  There is something that is morally wrong about a person who will execute someone for a sin they themselves will commit.

So then, what are we supposed to learn from it?  I think a lot of it is simply human life.  Shakespeare is famous for his saying, "Some rise by sin, and some by virtue fall" because it states to eloquently the truth.  Life is not 'just.'

"The greatest minds are capable of the greatest vices as well as of the greatest virtues."
  - Rene Descartes


It then comes down to what we do with what we have, rather than just what we have.  Shakespeare writes about people who have great opportunities given them, like William III, Henry V (Hal), Macbeth, etc. and then about what they do with it.  Some people fail, some rise and succeed.  Shakespeare also discusses the responsibility those who have power hold.



"Those with great power, have great responsibility."
  - Spider Man's Uncle.

Being a hero is less about where we stand in life, than what we do.

Comments (3)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
There is a long tradition of interpreting Shakespeare on a broad philosophical level as you are beginning to do here. I'm glad that you quoted Isabella, but you should try to trace these themes a bit more closely in conjunction with the text. Of course death is a major theme in Shakespeare's plays and poetry, and you could also look across his other works on this idea (or other texts, such as John Donne, whom you quote in your post title).

Be careful about embedding a video without introducing it or commenting upon it. Videos are everywhere. Why should I look at this one? It's sometimes useful to point visitors to specific elements to watch for in a clip you provide, or to ask them to respond to something in it.
1 reply · active 739 weeks ago
Alright, I'll try to work on that. I should have taken more time with this post, the ideas are good, but they needed more fleshing out. I'll try to be more . . . philosophical/analytical in upcoming posts like this
I love Shakespeare's sense of humor. In all of his comedies, as well as his other plays, during comical moments his characters that we are laughing at are almost always oblivous to the joke. Often their very seriousness, and unawareness provides the very dry humor that makes the jokes funny. This movie clip accentuates how much each person must stay in their serious character, even though it is from one of his comedies.

Post a new comment

Comments by